Sacking season is here. While players are busy playing for their countries or hitting the beach, ownership at Premier League clubs are taking the opportunity to evaluate their leadership direction.
No one would have predicted the plight of Michael Carrick entering this season. The former Manchester United midfielder took interim charge of a sleepwalking squad last January and led the Red Devils to an improbable top four finish, earning more points than any other club from the point of his taking the reins and the end of the Premier League season. Now a season that was looked forward to with great expectation has gone completely off the rails and Carrick has paid the price. Just six months after securing a permanent deal, Carrick is out as the Manchester United manager and Mauricio Pochettinno is next man up. The Argentine will be the fourth manager to direct the squad since the INEOS group led by Jim Ratcliffe was tasked with righting the ship at Old Trafford in February 2024. Understandably, supporters are less than impressed with Ratcliffe and his corporate henchmen. The only trophy to be put on the shelf was won by the manger Ratcliffe inherited and then fired, Eric ten Hag.
Things finally looked like they were clicking at the end of last season. It should be noted, however, that Carrick was aided by the absence of any other competition but for the Premier League. So low had the club fallen that Manchester United had no European or domestic cup matches from the time of his appointment. There were no domestic cups or European competitions to distract Carrick’s efforts on the training pitch. One cannot discount the remarkable run that landed the Red Devils third in the table, behind only Arsenal and Manchester City. Thus, it was shocking how badly this team stumbled out of the gate this season. Anything that happened last season pales to the horror of Manchester United sitting in the relegation zone. All the excuses in the world, and any real squad deficiencies still do not equate the Red Devils with a relegation team. A frightened ownership felt forced to make a move. We can confirm Michael Carrick has departed his role as men’s first-team head coach.
Pochettino must now pick up the pieces and try to reverse a downward trajectory that was interrupted only by ten Hag’s and Carrick’s momentary success. The backing he will receive from an unpopular ownership group awaits to be seen. The squad is thin and bereft of stars outside of Bruno Fernandes. Financial problems, once unthinkable for one of England’s most august and successful clubs, limit the amount of investment which will be available to Pochettino. Ratcliffe has angered an already frustrated supporter base by firing hundreds of off the field Manchester United employees while underinvesting in the transfer market, proclaiming the club is in danger of going bust. Good luck Mauricio.
Carrick, meanwhile, evidenced far more professionalism than ownership exhibited toward him in the past few weeks. The former Manchester United midfielder player retains a great love for the club despite being clearly mistreated in recent weeks when he continued to train with players while ownership negotiated with Pochettino.
Carrick now joins Pierre Sage on the unemployment line. Sage experienced no success and inspired no hope in undertaking the challenging task of replacing Oliver Glasner at Crystal Palace. Glasner led the Eagles to Europa Conference League and English FA Cup trophies in the most successful run in the club’s history. Sage had the Eagles sitting at the absolute bottom of the Premier League table. There were no signs that things would improve as the French manger seemed overwhelmed in his first Premier League role, making few changes or adaptations to a plan gone horribly wrong. The Crystal Palace defense is a shambles. The Eagles have conceded more goals than any other Premier League team, earning their bottom spot in the table. A 5-0 humiliating loss to bitter rival Brighton will be the most remembered moment of the brief Sage era.
Criticism of Crystal Palace Chairman Steve Parrish ranges from making a poor hiring selection to player transfer failures to not giving Sage enough time. Sometimes, things just do not work out. Sage was Manager of the Year in the French league last season and, despite a short resume, would have seemed a rising star. Crystal Palace necessarily operates on a tight player budget given its lower to mid-tier revenues among Premier League clubs. Despite coming under regular criticism for perceived stinginess, it was Parrish who rescued a Crystal Palace club that was in administration and has now kept them in the Premier League for fourteen seasons. Glasner provided moments of glory. Parrish has kept the small south London club north of the relegation line for an extended period. He was not going to gamble that run on Sage.
Thomas Frank, the former Brentford and Tottenham Hotspur manager, was named the new Crystal Palace manager on Tuesday. Frank was unsuccessful at Spurs but had a remarkable run of success with Brentford which, like Palace, is a smaller club trying to punch above its weight. It could be a good fit. Frank is seen as a culture builder who grated with some of the stronger player personalities at a larger club like Tottenham Hotspur. Prior to his failure at Spurs, Frank was widely admired for guiding Brentford to promotion out of the Championship and establishing them in the Premier League. His seven years with Brentford included four post promotion Premier League seasons, impressive when so many promoted sides quickly fall victim to relegation. Frank’s accomplishments with the Bees should not be obscured by the difficulties at Tottenham Hotspur, difficulties which have taken down other managers as well.